If there’s
one part of the world I should watch more movies from it’s definitely Asia. Every
now and then I do decide to watch Asian cinema and it rarely disappoints me,
but somehow I am not watching as many as I should. Why this is? Not a clue.
Maybe the big cultural difference compared to the ‘conventional’ Hollywood
movies I grew up with and defined my standards. Yesterday I decided it was
about time to watch the 3 hour long Yi Yi
from Taiwan, and boy was it worth my time!
The movie
portrays a family living in Taipei. We kick off with a wedding where the whole
family is presented to us. The family is shortly forced to take care of their
grandmother who is in a coma. In a network narrative the movie mainly follows
four family members starting with the dad NJ, who is unhappy in his job and
forced to do business with a Japanese videogame company associate, making him
aware of the purely commercial aim of his colleagues. When he runs into an old
flame he evaluates his entire life and being. His youngest, 8 year old son Yang
Yang, has trouble with his teachers and female students and likes to make
photographs. His daughter is getting involved with the boyfriend of her friend
who lives next door. Finally we follow NJ’s brother-in-law who has a lot of
trouble with his newly wed involving an ex-girlfriend who shows up at their
baby shower.
The
strength of this film is the universality of the story. Even though it plays in
Taiwan, the stories are those of every day life and could be yours or mine just
as well. It never dramatizes or wants to be pretentious, it simply shows us the
lives of the different generations in a family and what they are dealing with.
The length of 173 minutes never feels too long, again nothing special or
spectacular happens in this movie but it gets your attention from the first to
last minute. The final scene brings all the members together and is simply
brilliant. A movie that gets under your skin with ease without ever forcing
anything.
Of course from
a Hollywood perspective associations with movies like Magnolia or Babel can be
made. The main difference between those two titles and Yi Yi is the fact that I would call this movie more modest and
calm. The story doesn’t really build up to a climax but nevertheless fascinated
me until the last second. It sounds corny, but this is really a movie about
life, nothing more and nothing less. The writer-director Edward Yang deserves a
lot of credit (received the best director award at Cannes) for making such a
delicate and pure picture. I couldn’t pick one or two scenes that make
the difference, it really is a movie as a whole, demonstrating the brilliance
of the writer. If I had to pick one scene though there is a wonderful sequence
where NJ and his former love are evaluating their lives, which reminded me of Richard
Linklater’s Before Sunset, but again
I have a Hollywood reference frame.
Yi Yi impressed me deeply and it likely might end up
as one of my personal favorites (I suspect a second viewing will impress me
even more). I will not spend too many words, just watch this ‘small’
masterpiece. I will for sure search for more Asian films like this. Comes
highly recommended!
10/10
Goede review, maar ik vraag me af waarom zoveel (professionele) reviewers deze film zo hoog waarderen. Misschien moet ik hem nog een keer zien, maar ik gaf 'm maar een 7,5-8 cijfer destijds... Ik vond het niet zo'n bijzondere film, en vooral het jongetje irriteerde me op den duur, omdat het een beetje leek alsof hij als 'schattigheids-factor' was ingezet om de film daardoor beter of aandoenlijker te maken. Zeker in de eindscene waar je hem met z'n rugzakje bij de begrafenis van zijn opa zag, was het me iets te goedkoop schattig gemaakt, te duidelijk tranentrekkend bedacht. Ook van Yang's "A brighter summer day" was ik niet ondersteboven, dus misschien houd ik gewoon niet zo van de stijl van Edward Yang...
ReplyDeleteGr. Titus
Wat voor mij alles uitmaakt in deze film is de weg ernaar toe. Ik snap je punt vd schattigheidsfactor, iets waar ik me in bepaalde films ook mateloos aan kan storen. In deze film echter lijkt met deze laatste scene en de voorgaande acties van het jongetje veel op zijn plaats te vallen. Kwam voor mij absoluut niet goedkoop of gemaakt over. Als losse scene zou ik dit mogelijk ook gevonden hebben.
DeleteHmm, ik ga hem binnenkort wel nog een keer zien en dan kom ik erop terug. :)
DeleteGr. Titus